Equal Pay Day Guide: Navigating and Correcting Benefits Inequity in the Workplace

Workplaces are vibrant and evolving – so why isn’t compensation keeping up?

It's high time we peel back the layers of the standard equity conversation to reveal its more subtle and insidious counterparts. You see, when we talk about inequity, we're not just battling the age-old gender pay gap demon; we're up against a hydra — one head in the form of tangible cash disparities and others manifesting through the less tangible, yet equally crippling, disparities in benefits. Which head is going to devour us first? How do we slay all these monsters? Does anyone have the energy??

This discussion isn't merely academic; it's a call to arms for Equal Pay Day (for white women only), urging us not just to illuminate but to eradicate these deep-seated imbalances.

The Not-so-Secret Life of the Gender Pay Gap

Here we are, once again, (“torn into pieces…” Kelly Clarkson, anyone?) talking about the gender pay gap. 

You'd think this relic of workplace inequality would've been banished to the annals of history by now, but alas, it stubbornly persists. It's like that old, faded wallpaper that, no matter how much you scrape, refuses to leave your walls in peace. What kind of glue is corporate America using that’s made this thing so sticky?

The disparity in earnings between genders is more than a statistic; it's a stark reminder of the systemic obstacles that continue to hinder true equality in our workplaces. But it's not just about fairness; it's about the message we're sending to over half the population (!) — that their work is somehow less valuable. With every cent discrepancy, we're perpetuating an outdated narrative that has no place in our modern world.

Take a deep breath because these data points are about to enrage you.

Let’s start light. In 2024, the gender pay gap has shown some nuanced shifts. According to Payscale, “when data are controlled, the 2024 gender pay gap closes for occupations in Building & Grounds Cleaning & Maintenance, Legal, Installation, Maintenance, & Repair, and Management.” However, significant gaps remain in areas like Education, Training, & Library, and Sales & Related, with women earning $0.90 and $0.92 respectively for every dollar earned by men when adjusted for comparable factors. The report also highlighted that women who work from home face a larger uncontrolled pay gap at $0.79 compared to men, and this gap varies based on the amount of remote work. 

Interestingly, women more willing to change jobs tend to see a narrower pay gap. (Why should we have to go through the rigamarole of job hopping to make more money?) There's also an encouraging sign for women of color as the controlled pay gap has closed significantly since 2019 - but still not enough - particularly for Black, American Indian and Native Alaskan, and Hispanic women. 

  • Black women earn 67 cents for every dollar earned by white, non-Hispanic men. (Idealist.org)
  • Hispanic or Latina women earn 54 cents on the dollar. (Idealist.org)
  • Native American women working full-time, year-round make on average 59 cents on the dollar. (AAUW
  • Alaska Athabascan women earn 68 cents, according to data from 2017 to 2021. (The 19th)
  • Workers with disabilities earn a median wage of 66 cents for each $1 earned by workers without disabilities. (Center for American Progress)

There's still a significant gap at the executive level where women, particularly Hispanic women, face wider pay disparities.

The Department of Labor reported that in 2023, women working full-time and year-round were paid, on average, 83.7% as much as men, translating to a $10,000 yearly difference. They are actively addressing this issue with initiatives aimed at increasing equity in federal programs and the workforce, particularly impacting women of color and those with disabilities who face larger gaps.

Statista's 2023 data reflects the racial pay gap, showing significant differences in median household incomes among different racial and ethnic groups. For instance, the median income of White households stands notably higher than that of Black households.

Overall, while there have been improvements, especially for women of color, there's still a long way to go in achieving full pay equity across genders and races. The persistent wage gaps, particularly pronounced in certain industries and levels of employment, highlight the ongoing need for structural changes and policy interventions to address these disparities effectively.

Understanding and Addressing Workplace Inequities: A Comprehensive Approach

Through the Looking Glass – Why We See Things Differently

The perception gap in the workplace between men and women can often feel like viewing the world through differently tinted glasses (some rose-colored, some broken). This gap can impact the dynamics between employees and the overall culture within an organization.

In many workplaces, men may perceive their environment as open and merit-based, believing that opportunities are equally available to everyone and that rewards are the direct result of hard work and talent. This perspective aligns with the traditional view of meritocracy, where the best and hardest-working individuals, regardless of their background, rise to the top.

Women may view the same workplace differently, feeling as though they are navigating a complex landscape filled with subtle biases, invisible barriers, and unspoken rules. And as a woman, I can say that it is exhausting. 

These could include gender-based expectations, unequal access to networking opportunities, or a lack of representation in leadership roles, which might make the path to advancement seem more convoluted and challenging than it appears to their male counterparts.

This disparity in perceptions is troubling and a barrier to creating a cohesive and inclusive work environment. It hinders the development of a culture where all employees feel valued, heard, and have equal opportunities to succeed. Failure to recognize and address these different experiences can lead to dissatisfaction, reduced productivity, and a higher turnover rate, especially among women. And let’s not forget about the toxic culture it breeds. The domino effect of inequity can dismantle a team's spirit and erode a company's reputation, making it imperative to address these issues holistically.

So where do we begin? Surely increasing pay for women is enough, right? WRONG.

Addressing Workplace Inequities: The Hidden Challenges Beyond the Paycheck

When we peel back the layers (it’s like an onion), we find that inequity seeps far beyond salary differences and rears its ugly head yet again within the less conspicuous realm of benefits. 

You know that total compensation is complex–I don’t need to tell you that. But it’s worth noting that there are plenty of areas ripe for improvement in offering equitable packages to all employees.

Benefits equity extends past basic health insurance and retirement plans—and we know those things are table stakes these days, anyway. It encompasses a variety of elements crucial to an employee's life and satisfaction within their role. You’ve likely read it somewhere on the internet or heard it at an HR conference by now:

One size does not fit all in the world of benefits.

While some of us are living that flexible-work, comprehensive-benefits dream, others are left juggling life without the safety net of supportive work policies. And let me tell you, this isn't just a women's issue; it's an everyone issue, but women, particularly those handling the lion's share of caregiving, are feeling the brunt.

Here's where the gap widens: not everyone accesses these benefits equally. Hidden inequities in benefit structures can inadvertently favor one group over another, leaving some employees feeling undervalued and unsupported. For instance, if parental leave policies are more favorable towards mothers than fathers, or if you’re offering only fertility benefits instead of family benefits, or if your shiny new benefit is student loan repayment, but the majority of your staff doesn’t have student debt. If flexible working conditions are only available to certain levels of staff and you’re offering internet reimbursement to only your US-based employees, we're not just talking about perks—we're discussing fundamental elements that contribute to an employee's well-being and ability to perform. 

And then you need to ask yourself, why are you offering this form of additional compensation to some but not all?

Now, onto the buzzkill stats from our friends over at McKinsey. Microaggressions at work? They're not "micro" in impact. These little digs and unintentional slights pile up, particularly for women and even more so for women from marginalized communities. And flexible work? It's not just a nice-to-have; it's become a must-have, especially for working mamas out there and those with disabilities.

However, let's not get too comfy here. While we're making some strides, there's a whole lot of room for improvement. SHRM (and take this with a grain of salt, although we know the following is patently true) shows that many companies are talking a big DE&I game, but when it comes down to brass tacks – aka funding and real action – the follow-through is more like a whisper than a shout.

Bridging the Benefits Gap

The task at hand is not small, but it is clear: we need to dig deep to unearth these hidden inequities and address them head-on. This involves a comprehensive review of current benefits packages, listening to employee feedback, and understanding the diverse needs of the entire workforce. 

It's about creating an environment where all employees, regardless of gender, family status, or position, feel equally valued and supported.

Employers must embrace transparency, not just in salaries but in how benefits are distributed and utilized. It's about communication—ensuring that all team members are aware of and understand how to access the benefits available to them. Perhaps most importantly, it involves tailoring benefits to meet the varied needs of a diverse workforce, ensuring that policies are inclusive and supportive of everyone's unique life situations.

The tldr; here is that crafting equitable benefits packages is a critical step toward fostering a truly inclusive workplace. It's a move that acknowledges the multifaceted nature of equity and addresses the complete spectrum of employee needs. 

By doing so, organizations are that much more attractive to those on the job hunt, and it keeps current employees happy, too. Those people are your greatest asset and loudest brand champions. Treat them right.

Alright, before I leave you, I want you to part with something particularly useful. Here’s a step-by-step guide (a short and sweet one since you made it through this lengthy tirade) to fixing your inequitable benefits package.

Your cart